I can help here, because I was wondering the same thing. Our counter says says 59 when in fact it’s 61. So you’re caching it somewhere to reduce the number of times the widget hits google? I can live with that, but I’m curious what the update frequency is? Is it weekly?
Hi there and welcome to the Community, @Chris_Cacioppo 
The cache time for our Reviews apps is 72 hours. If it’s been more than 72 hours and the new reviews still didn’t appear, please let me know. I’ll be happy to check things for you 